THREE MINUTE THESIS

WEDNESDAY 14 JUNE 2023

6PM, RON COOKE HUB

About three minute Thesis (3MT)

A challenge against the clock

First developed by the University of Queensland in 2008, Three Minute Thesis (or 3MT) competitions are designed to challenge PhD researchers to explain their research effectively, and concisely, to a non-specialist audience in just three minutes - helping to develop their presentation and research communication skills. For comparison, the average 80,000 word written thesis would take nearly 9 hours to present!

Why is 3MT important?

Communicating to different audiences helps demonstrate the contribution that research makes to wider society and the economy. The University of York 3MT® is a chance for our postgraduate researchers to engage and enthuse a range of learners about their work.

10 Years of York 3MT

We're incredibly proud that this year marked our 10th anniversary of running this exciting event.

Presented as part of the 2023 York Festival of Ideas, our 11 finalists had just three minutes to explain how their research is helping society to Rediscover, Reimagine & Rebuild the future.

In addition to our first, second and third place prizes decided by our judging panel, our live audience had the chance to choose their favourite speaker, and secure them a coveted People's Choice Award. We're thrilled to say our overall first place winner will now go on to compete at the national 3MT final.

Scroll on below to find out more!

2023 FINALISTS

The hidden side of depression: what's in a metaphor?
aNGELOS Sofocleous

Summary

In my research, I examine testimonies, memoirs, and autobiographies by depressed individuals to better understand the experience of depression. 

Depressed individuals often report feelings of suffocation, drowning, incarceration, being in another world, or in a bubble. The challenge lies in understanding the common thread that connects these seemingly disparate metaphors and what they reveal about the experience of depression. What these metaphors share, I argue, is the feeling of being a spectator: observing the world pass by without being able to participate in it. In fact, depressed individuals frequently describe their existence as resembling mannequins in a store window or spectators at a theatre play—observers disconnected from the world's activities.

With 300 million people globally affected by depression, it is imperative that we actively listen to those who endure its grasp and gain a profound understanding of their experiences through their own narratives.

About Angelos

Angelos Sofocleous is a fourth-year PhD candidate in Philosophy at the University of York. His research centres around the philosophy of experiences with depression. He aims to gain a deeper understanding of how interpersonal relationships are affected by depression and the underlying meaning behind various metaphors used by individuals when describing their depression experiences, such as feeling alienated, suffocated, incarcerated, or being a spectator. In addition to his academic pursuits, Angelos enjoys writing, poetry, and photography.

"With 300 million people globally affected by depression, it is imperative we actively listen..."

"With 300 million people globally affected by depression, it is imperative we actively listen..."

    "FND is still relatively unknown to both the public and to healthcare workers "

    "FND is still relatively unknown to both the public and to healthcare workers "

      ‘It’s all in your head’: the experiences of patients with functional neurological disorder
      Danielle Varley

      Summary

      Functional neurological disorder (FND) is a condition where a person experiences unexplained neurological symptoms (such as seizures, difficulty swallowing, or tremors) that are not thought to be caused by a neurological or medical condition. Although we have been aware of FND for over two thousand years, and it is the second most common disorder seen in neurology clinics, FND is still relatively unknown to both the public and to healthcare workers.

      As the symptoms of FND are so diverse, healthcare workers may struggle in diagnosing the condition. Diagnosing and treating FND patients can be especially difficult as there are currently no UK clinical guidelines to guide healthcare workers on the clinical management of FND. My PhD research aims to understand how FND is being diagnosed and treated in the NHS and explore the lived experiences of patients undergoing these diagnostic and treatment processes in the UK.

      About Danielle

      Danielle is a final-year PhD student based in the Department of Health Sciences. Danielle holds an undergraduate degree in Psychology and a master’s degree in Health Psychology.

      Previously, she worked as a clinical researcher in the NHS and in academia for 10 years, researching a wide range of mental and physical health conditions affecting people of all ages. Danielle’s PhD aims to investigate how functional neurological disorder (FND) is diagnosed and treated in the NHS and understand patient experiences.

      DNA: Storing data for GENErations
      Francisca D'Rozario

      Summary

      In today’s world, there is a never-ending need to store digital photos, documents, videos etc in devices such as smartphones, laptops, CDs, hard drives and the “cloud”. Data centres around the world consume a vast amount of electricity and their growth will be unsustainable beyond the next decade. Therefore, it is vital to switch to stable and environment-friendly data storage methods.

      DNA, prepared in a laboratory, can solve these issues. DNA can store dense amounts of data, lasting up to 1,000 years and reduce the energy consumption by 1,000 times compared to present data centres. My research focuses on DNA structures called DNA switches, which can switch between two different structural forms when subjected to acids and bases, making one form data-readable and the other not. DNA switches, integrated into electronics, have the potential to serve as dense and durable data storage devices, saving energy and sparing the planet’s health!

      About Francisca

      Francisca is a second-year PhD student in the School of Physics, Engineering and Technology. Her research involves studying DNA bound to gold surfaces with potential applications in Electronics and Information Technology. Besides her research, Fran loves to dance, play korfball and go bouldering with her friends.

      "DNA can store dense amounts of data and reduce energy consumption"

      "DNA can store dense amounts of data and reduce energy consumption"

        "The aim is to build a picture of families' lives and inform local decision-making"

        "The aim is to build a picture of families' lives and inform local decision-making"

          The 'Routine Data' Jigsaw: Completing the picture to improve health
          Hollie Henderson

          Summary

          Routine data represents the information that is collected about us when we interact with public services, such as health, education and social care. The Born and Bred in (BaBi) network is a collection of studies that gain permission from pregnant women, to join together the data that are routinely collected about them and their baby for research. The aim is to build a picture of families' lives and inform local decision-making. The early years of life are a critical phase for child development and have been a key policy focus. However, there is limited evidence of routine data informing decision-making in this area. My research explores whether data from the BaBi studies can be used to inform early-years decisions. If we can understand the challenges of using routine data for decision-making, we can work to overcome these, to allow for better informed decisions around early life health.

          About Hollie

          Hollie is a third-year PhD student in the Department of Health Sciences and is funded by the White Rose Consortium. Her research focuses on how pieces of data that are routinely collected by public services can be linked together for research and used to inform decisions around early life health. Hollie is passionate about conducting research that can help reduce health inequalities and improve the lives of people on low incomes. 

          Preventing Mental Ill-health in Refugee Girls through Social-Emotional Skills Education
          Jessie shepherd

          Summary

          Approximately 1 in 6 UK school children are diagnosed with a mental health issue, a sharp rise from 5 years ago. Social and emotional skills education is one way to combat this crisis; with research suggesting social and emotional skills are tied to academic achievement, increased well-being, and decreased risk of mental ill-health. All primary schools in the UK teach social and emotional skills, but the effectiveness varies especially for some students, like refugee girls (who are five times as likely to develop a mental health disorder).

          My research looks at teaching practices of social and emotional skills for refugee girls. By targeting one high-need group, my research hopes to understand how schools can adapt social and emotional skills education to support all high-need students. Ultimately this could improve social and emotional skills education and decrease mental ill-health for all students.

          About Jessie

          Jessie Shepherd is a licensed therapist from the USA and a PhD student in Psychology in Education. Jessie’s research focuses on issues of equity that impact well-being of high-risk groups and how to decrease mental ill-health. Her PhD research is on teaching practices influencing refugee and migrant girls' social and emotional skills education.

          "this could... decrease mental ill-health for all students."

          "this could... decrease mental ill-health for all students."

            "Autistic people have been around for years, and are here to stay."

            "Autistic people have been around for years, and are here to stay."

              Thinking Differently: Autism in the Stone Age and evolution
              Katharine Macy

              Summary

              Autism is a neurotype that is often seen as a disability. Japanese macaques and chimpanzees have genes and behaviours indicating autism, implying that autism has been around for thousands of years. Different neurotypes include autistic people and non-autistic, or neurotypical, people and each type has their own thing that they are good at. Along with all our individual differences, autistic people and neurotypical people also have differing behaviours. For example, neurotypical people prefer imitating, where they copy things precisely, and autistic people prefer emulating, which is where you do similar things but change things slightly. Sometimes, imitation is better and other times emulation is better. Having the option of both increases the success of a group, or in this case, humanity. Autistic people have been around for years, and are here to stay.

              About Katharine

              Katharine is a third-year archaeology PhD student at the University of York, where they also obtained their MA in Early Prehistory and Human Origins. Their research explores autism in the early Stone Age (Palaeolithic) and they use their own experience as an autistic person to make their research community-orientated. Katharine uses psychology and archaeology to bring together an understanding of autism in a new light and is a political activist in their spare time, working on autistic policy and more.

              Chemical Contaminants in Botswana’s Fragile Aquatic Systems
              Kgato Selwe

              Summary

              The occurrence of chemical contaminants in the environment is a global concern and it is essential that their levels are monitored closely as many of these compounds, eg pharmaceuticals, are designed to produce effects at very low concentrations. 

              Monitoring of chemical pollutants has been possible due to increased capability of analytical instrumentation and methodology. However, one significant challenge in environmental monitoring of chemical contaminants is that investigations are limited to developed countries due to the availability of analytical instrumentation. To address this, we evaluate the presence of chemical pollutants in Botswana’s aquatic systems using state of the art instrumentation and methodologies.

              About Kgato

              Kgato Selwe is a final-year Chemistry PhD Student. His research investigates the occurrence of contaminants of emerging concern in the very fragile aquatic systems of Botswana with focus on the presence and fate of illicit drugs and anti-retroviral compounds. Kgato is an advocate for equality and diversity in the workplace and continues to dedicate efforts towards decolonisation of the Chemistry curriculum at the University of York.

              "The occurrence of chemical contaminants in the environment is a global concern"

              "The occurrence of chemical contaminants in the environment is a global concern"

                "Human activities have irreversibly changed the world's natural environments"

                "Human activities have irreversibly changed the world's natural environments"

                  Walk on the re-wild side: bringing back buffalo to benefit big beautiful birds
                  Louisa Mamalis

                  Summary

                  Human activities have irreversibly changed the world's natural environments putting almost all species at risk of extinction.

                  The giant ibis is one such threatened bird species, living solely within Cambodia, where there are around 200 individuals. This small population is declining due to hunting and the loss of forest habitat. The giant ibis relies on waterholes, which are also declining due to habitat destruction, climate change and loss of large mammals that historically maintained them. My research aims to explore rewilding techniques to restore waterholes to support the giant ibis and other species that rely on waterholes. We are introducing domestic buffalo to waterholes to try and recreate the natural processes lost through the decline of large mammals such as elephants and wild cattle in Cambodia. We are assessing the effectiveness of the wallowing and grazing actions of buffalo to improve waterhole conditions to support species such as the giant ibis.

                  About Louisa

                  Lou is a third-year biology PhD student at the University of York, working within the Leverhulme Centre for Anthropocene Biodiversity. Lou is interested in landscape level ecology and conservation, with a particular focus on birds. When not chipping away at her PhD she also enjoys bird and plant identification whilst hiking as well as running and swimming.

                  Providing early years support through volunteers: for whose benefit?
                  Louise Padgett

                  Summary

                  Volunteers play important roles in the delivery of our health services including those that support families in the early years of their infant’s life. These services are important in supporting the healthy development of children and preventing long term negative impacts on their health and prospects. But why should volunteers be considered to deliver these important services rather than paid staff or professionals? 

                  My research explores the wider consequences of volunteers delivering early years services on the volunteer, organisation and wider community, to determine if having volunteers provide the support can generate wider value. Through exploring the existing literature and interviewing volunteers, managers and funders of early years services, I am exploring how volunteer models can maximise the value of an early years service. The findings of this research are providing knowledge for those designing and funding early years services as to if and why volunteers models should be considered.

                  About Louise

                  Louise Padgett is a final-year PhD student in the Department of Health Sciences. Her research interests include the evaluation of public health interventions using qualitative and evidence synthesis research methods. Louise has experiences of working within the voluntary sector to support volunteer-led community health interventions and is now researching the role and impact of volunteers in the delivering of early years services. 

                  "Volunteers play important roles in the delivery of our health services"

                  "Volunteers play important roles in the delivery of our health services"

                    "We may be one step closer to clean, renewable hydrogen fuel production on a large scale."

                    "We may be one step closer to clean, renewable hydrogen fuel production on a large scale."

                      Thin films: tiny materials with tremendous potential
                      Matthew Hill

                      Summary

                      Semiconductors are the building blocks of modern technology. They contribute to almost every digital application you can think of, including laptops and mobile phones, and even social infrastructure such as the internet. As such, they have gone further than any other material in shaping the modern, interconnected world. Many semiconductors exist as thin films, which can be up to 4,000 times thinner than a strand of human hair! It is their conveniently tiny size that allows them to play their role in tackling global problems. One such problem is the ongoing climate crisis. My research involves creating semiconductor thin films for use as catalysts in producing clean, carbon-free hydrogen fuel from just water and sunlight. By developing a deeper understanding of the physics and chemistry behind the process used to create these thin films, we may be one step closer to clean, renewable hydrogen fuel production on a large scale.

                      About Matthew

                      Matthew Hill is a third-year PhD researcher in Physics at the University of York, and is based at the York Plasma Institute. His research interests lie in plasma physics, thin films, and plasma-based solutions to renewable energy sources. Outside of his research, he loves hiking, gaming, and playing guitar and saxophone.

                      Why can I count chairs, tables and sofas, but not furniture?
                      Victoria Noble

                      Summary

                      In English, I can count chairs, tables, and sofas: one chair, two tables, three sofas. However, I cannot count furniture - at least not in the same way that I count chairs: three furnitures? Similar patterns are seen in Welsh, but for nouns that refer to insects or seeds, and in Mandarin Chinese, all nouns are like furniture. Why should languages not let us count certain nouns whose referents are easily countable?

                      My research aims to figure out the extent to which our languages, a uniquely human trait, are shaped by the structure of the world. In this case, how groups of things (like furniture or insects) may bring a grouphood property from our senses into the structure of some - but not all - languages. After all, we're all interacting with the same world, so why should our languages choose whether or not human experiences are reflected in their structures?

                      About Victoria

                      Based in the Department of Language and Linguistic Science, Victoria's research interests are in formal semantics and the syntax-semantics interface, with a particular focus on countability, individuation and plurality across world languages. Keen on outreach, Victoria has led on various public engagement projects including gamifying her research for primary and secondary school children, with the aim of celebrating the rich diversity of world languages in fun and educational ways.

                      "Our languages, a uniquely human trait, are shaped by the structure of the world."

                      "Our languages, a uniquely human trait, are shaped by the structure of the world."

                        2023 WINNERS

                        1ST PLACE

                        Angelos Sofocleous, Department of Philosophy

                        The Hidden Side of Depression: What's in a Metaphor

                        2ND PLACE

                        Katharine Macy, Department of Archaeology

                        Thinking Differently: Autism in the Stone Age and evolution

                        3RD PLACE

                        Jessie Shepherd, Department of Education

                        Preventing Mental Ill-health in Refugee Girls through Social Emotional Skills Education

                        PEOPLE'S CHOICE

                        Francisca D'Rozario, School of Physics, Engineering and Technology

                        DNA: Storing data for GENErations

                        JUDGING PANEL AND PRESENTERS

                        Our 2023 judging panel and presenters

                        In addition to our People's Choice Award, the work of our 3MT finalists will also be reviewed by our panel, for first, second and third place prizes. This year, we are delighted to welcome members of our panel from a wide range of disciplines to help us choose our winner.

                        Read on below for a bit of background on each of our panelists and speakers across the day.

                        Judges

                        Professor Kate Arnold

                        Dean of the York Graduate Research School and Professor of Ecology in the Environment and Geography Department, University of York

                        Having been Dean of the York Graduate Research School since September 2020, Kate has strategic oversight of over 2,400 postgraduate researchers.

                        An ecologist by background, for over 20 years she has carried out research at the interface of science, policy and regulation. Her current projects, based in York's Department of Environment and Geography, are investigating the effects of environmental change, including chemical contaminants and habitat management, on wildlife.

                        From 2018-2020, she worked for Defra heading up an EU exit strategy team focusing on circular economy and single-use plastic policies.

                        Professor Kate Arnold, Dean of the York Graduate Research School (University of York)

                        Dr Ruth Penfold-Mounce

                        Deputy Head of Department and Senior Lecturer in Criminology in the Sociology Department, University of York

                        Ruth is a Senior Lecturer in Criminology in the Sociology Department at the University of York. Her background in Sociology is united with an interest in crime, death studies and popular culture and celebrity. She is a passionate advocate for creative and innovative teaching and learning such as walking pedagogy.

                        Ruth has established the Death and Culture Network (DaCNet) at York. This network runs a biannual international conference as well the Death and Culture Book Series (Bristol University Press). She is regularly asked to speak at academic events and does much public engagement work particularly through the annual York Dead Good Festival and York Festival of Ideas. In addition to this, she has also filmed with both the BBC’s Hairy Bikers and BBC Four, recorded with BBC Radio 4, and written for award-nominated blogs and scholarly sites such as The Conversation.

                        Laura Wiggins

                        York 3MT Winner 2022

                        As our most recent first-place 3MT winner for her talk, ‘Eye spy with my little eye….a chemo-resistant cancer cell!’, Laura's research involves the use of machine learning and time-lapse imaging to track cancer cell behaviour, and detect cells that continue to thrive despite being treated with chemotherapy.

                        Laura has designed a user-friendly app called ‘CellPhe’ so that others can make use of her methods with just a few clicks of a button.

                        Professor Doug Cleaver

                        Director of the Doctoral School at the Materials and Engineering Research Institute (Sheffield Hallam University), and Chair of the UK Council for Graduate Education

                        Having originally studied physics, Doug is now a Professor of Materials Modelling, publishing regularly in the field of soft condensed matter, and running projects with the likes of Unilever, HP and Seiko-EPSON. He has also been academic lead for research degrees at Sheffield Hallam University (SHU) since 2011, and introduced a Doctoral School there in 2014. 

                        Doug has supervised over 20 doctorates to completion and examined even more – with one of his PhD students going on to win the national 3MT competition. He has also combined his scientific and postgraduate researcher specialties by helping to run the Institute of Physics ​“Bell Burnell Graduate Scholarship Fund”, devised to support doctoral students from groups that are currently under-represented in the discipline.

                        As well as his “day job” in Sheffield, Doug is Chair of the UK Council for Graduate Education, promoting best practice across the sector (and beyond), and shaping future priorities.

                        Dr Owen Gower

                        Director of the UK Council for Graduate Education

                        Owen is the Director of the UK Council for Graduate Education, where he leads the Council’s advocacy on a range of issues in postgraduate affairs, most recently in relation to widening participation. Owen has a background in engaging academic research in public policy, having previously worked as Programme Director for an educational charity, where he sought to build interdisciplinary collaborations on a range of social policy issues.

                        A keen advocate of partnerships between academia and the voluntary sector, he has managed a series of fixed term post-doctoral positions in the voluntary sector, developed a doctoral placement scheme, and served as a collaborative supervisor for a PhD studentship. Owen has a PhD in Philosophy, has published in his field and co-edited a book for Ashgate, and has taught at Birkbeck, KCL, and Royal Holloway. He is a member of the Philosophy of Education Society of Great Britain and a Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts.

                        Guest Speaker

                        Dr Clare Viney

                        Chief Executive Officer, Careers Research and Advisory Centre (CRAC) / Vitae

                        Clare took up the role of Chief Executive Officer of CRAC in October 2016. A strategic leader with over 20 years' advocacy, policy and external affairs experience, Clare is a Chartered Scientist and Chemist with extensive experience in the science community and not-for-profit sector. She is passionate about investing in future generations and those from diverse backgrounds and experiences, empowering people to realise their potential and achieve their career and development goals.

                        Prior to her role at CRAC Clare was with the Royal Society of Chemistry for 16 years in a variety of roles in membership, fundraising, science policy, communications and latterly leading Membership and External Affairs. Her role ensured that the Royal Society of Chemistry remains the most influential voice for Chemistry in the UK, Europe and beyond.

                        Event Compere

                        Dr Karen Clegg

                        Head of the Building Research and Innovation Capacity Team (BRIC) at the University of York

                        Karen provides strategic oversight of the professional development provision for postgraduate research students, research staff, fellows, principal investigators and doctoral supervisors. Karen has over 25 years experience working in academic and researcher development and is also now working to build research capacity and develop a positive institutional research culture at York. An elected member of the UK Council for Graduate Education (2020 - 2024) Karen instigated the UKCGE led UK Research Supervision Survey (UKRSS) which is part of the evidence base for the New Deal for Postgraduate Research and is currently supporting discussions with funders around CPD and the enhancement of supervision. 

                        Karen is a huge 3MT fan and has been compering the York event since 2013!

                        Professor Kate Arnold, Dean of the York Graduate Research School (University of York)

                        Professor Kate Arnold, Dean of the York Graduate Research School (University of York)

                        Dr Ruth Penfold-Mounce, Deputy Head of Department and Senior Lecturer in Criminology (University of York)

                        Dr Ruth Penfold-Mounce, Deputy Head of Department and Senior Lecturer in Criminology (University of York)

                        Laura Wiggins, York 3MT Winner 2022

                        Laura Wiggins, York 3MT Winner 2022

                        Professor Doug Cleaver, Professor of Materials Modelling (Sheffield Hallam University) and Chair of the UK Council for Graduate Education

                        Professor Doug Cleaver, Professor of Materials Modelling (Sheffield Hallam University) and Chair of the UK Council for Graduate Education

                        Dr Owen Gower, Director of the UK Council for Graduate Education

                        Dr Owen Gower, Director of the UK Council for Graduate Education

                        Dr Clare Viney, Chief Executive Officer, CRAC/Vitae

                        Dr Clare Viney, Chief Executive Officer, CRAC/Vitae

                        Dr Karen Clegg, Head of BRIC (University of York)

                        Dr Karen Clegg, Head of BRIC (University of York)

                        Judging Criteria and Prizes

                        2023 Prizes

                        1st place - iPad
                        Angelos Sofocleus, The Hidden Side of Depression: What's in a Metaphor?

                        2nd place - £150 voucher
                        Katharine Macy, Thinking Differently: Autism in the Stone Age and evolution

                        3rd place - £75 voucher
                        Jessie Shepherd, Preventing Mental Ill-health in Refugee Girls through Social-Emotional Skills Education

                        People's choice - £75 voucher
                        Francisca D’Rozario, DNA: Storing data for GENErations 

                        For first, second and third place, our panel worked to the following criteria:

                        Comprehension and content

                        • Did the presentation provide an understanding of the background and significance to the research question being addressed, while explaining terminology and avoiding jargon?
                        • Did the presentation clearly describe the impact and/or results of the research, including conclusions and outcomes?
                        • Did the presentation follow a clear and logical sequence?
                        • Was the thesis topic, research significance, results/impact and outcomes communicated in language appropriate to a non-specialist audience?
                        • Did the presenter spend adequate time on each element of their presentation - or did they elaborate for too long on one aspect or was the presentation rushed?

                        Engagement and communication

                        • Did the oration make the audience want to know more?
                        • Was the presenter careful not to trivialise or generalise their research?
                        • Did the presenter convey enthusiasm for their research?
                        • Did the presenter capture and maintain their audience's attention?
                        • Did the speaker have sufficient stage presence, eye contact and vocal range; maintain a steady pace, and have a confident stance?
                        • Did the PowerPoint slide enhance the presentation - was it clear, legible, and concise?