THREE MINUTE THESIS

SATURDAY 8 JUNE 2024

1PM, LAW AND SOCIOLOGY BUILDING

About three minute Thesis (3MT)

A challenge against the clock

First developed by the University of Queensland in 2008, Three Minute Thesis (or 3MT) competitions are designed to challenge PhD researchers to explain their research effectively, and concisely, to a non-specialist audience in just three minutes - helping to develop their presentation and research communication skills. For comparison, the average 80,000 word written thesis would take nearly nine hours to present!

Why is 3MT important?

Communicating to different audiences helps demonstrate the contribution that research makes to wider society and the economy. The University of York 3MT® is a chance for our postgraduate researchers to engage and enthuse a range of learners about their work.

The Power Of... 3MT

Presented as part of the 2024 York Festival of Ideas, our nine finalists had just three minutes to explain 'The Power Of' their research!

In addition to our first, second and third place prizes decided by our judging panel, our live audience had the chance to choose their favourite speaker, and secure them a coveted People's Choice Award. Our overall first place winner will now go on to compete at the national 3MT final.

Scroll on below to find out more!

2024 FINALISTS

The Dance of Money: Mapping Mexico's Municipal Spending Moves
Alejandro Moreno Jimenez

Summary

In my research, I unravel the intricate dance of public funds in Mexican municipalities, exploring how neighboring regions influence each other's spending decisions.

Through spatial analysis, I reveal the interconnected web of fiscal interactions shaping the allocation of public resources. By studying the spatial and temporal dynamics of public expenditure spillovers, I shed light on the complex relationships between municipalities and the impact of these interactions on local economies. This research not only deepens our understanding of fiscal federalism but also provides valuable insights for policymakers seeking to enhance the efficiency and equity of public spending in Mexico.

Join me on a journey through the colorful tapestry of Mexican municipal finances, where every coin moves in harmony with its neighbors, painting a vibrant picture of fiscal interdependence.

About Alejandro

Alejandro is a third-year PhD student in Economics at the University of York. His research focuses on identifying fiscal interactions between municipalities in Mexico through spatial economics. He is passionate about public finance and its relationship with politics. Besides his research, Alejandro likes to play video games and work out in the gym.

"...every coin moves in harmony with its neighbors..."

"...every coin moves in harmony with its neighbors..."

    "...reading wrong turns our assumptions about what counts as useful knowledge upside down."

    "...reading wrong turns our assumptions about what counts as useful knowledge upside down."

      A History of Useless Books
      Grace Murray

      Summary

      What does it mean for a book to be useful - and what might it mean for it to be useless?

      We've been asking these questions about books and reading for hundreds of years, but they're especially important today in the midst of political debates about the usefulness of the arts. My PhD thesis answers them by returning to the late sixteenth century, a couple of generations after print was introduced to England. Not unlike the rise of AI today, print shone a spotlight on the role technology plays in the way we learn new things.

      My research centres on sixteenth and seventeenth century 'how to' books, or instruction manuals, that promised their readers would learn how to do something socially useful, whether it be calligraphy or carpentry. By paying attention to where and how these books demanded to be read, as well as notes left in books by readers in the past, my research shows that the history of reading wrong turns our assumptions about what counts as useful knowledge upside down.

      About Grace

      Grace Murray is in the final year of her PhD in the Department of English and Related Literature, where her research on sixteenth and seventeenth-century 'how-to' books is funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council. She is committed to sharing arts and humanities research with a broader audience and has contributed to exhibitions with York Archaeological Trust, the British Library, and the National Trust during her PhD.

      Catching Cancer Resistance with Calling Cards
      Jack stenning

      Summary

      Breast cancer is the most diagnosed cancer in the world. 70% of breast cancers are driven by cells that have hacked the 'estrogen receptor' protein to promote uncontrolled growth. Around 1 in 4 patients will develop resistance to anti-estrogen therapies, but it's currently unclear why only some patient's tumours develop this resistance to treatment.

      My research uses calling cards to help understand why some patients become resistant to anti-estrogen therapy and others don't. I have created a mutant of estrogen that can tag its surroundings with calling cards so that we can track precisely how estrogen is driving resistant breast cancer. I have put the mutant estrogen into cancer cells that are either resistant or sensitive to treatment. All of the calling card tags can then be used to identify how estrogen is driving resistance to cancer treatment in order to develop new therapeutics that keep cancer vulnerable to treatment.

      About Jack

      Jack is in the third year of his White Rose DTP Studentship in Mechanistic Biology at the University of York. His background in biochemistry underpins his passion for research that could help others. When Jack isn't chipping away at big research questions, he is probably gardening, gaming or questing for treasure in his weekly Dungeons and Dragons game.

      "Breast cancer is the most diagnosed cancer in the world."

      "Breast cancer is the most diagnosed cancer in the world."

        "My project aims to design such a device... to detect a specific, but very faint, glow emitted by the bacteria"

        "My project aims to design such a device... to detect a specific, but very faint, glow emitted by the bacteria"

          Keeping liquids free from bacterial contamination
          Minahil Khan

          Summary

          Water contamination remains a concern in most countries without sufficient resources for proper treatment. The bacteria in contaminated water can be severely harmful to humans, causing diseases and even death. Detecting bacterial contamination in water used for consumption is a way to alleviate this issue while keeping costs accessible. For instance, an in-flow and real-time monitoring system could be a simple yet powerful solution for this problem.

          My project aims to design such a device using nanotechnology to detect a specific, but very faint, glow emitted by the bacteria due to the process of “autofluorescence”. This faint glow is very difficult to detect on its own, requiring expensive and sensitive instruments. I am designing and fabricating small chips with nanostructures that can enhance this faint glow, making the bacteria glow brighter. This device will be compact and can be installed on the liquid flow pipes for real-time monitoring.

          About Minahil

          Minahil is a second-year PhD student funded by Procter and Gamble in the School of Physics, Engineering and Technology at the University of York. Her research is on development of sensitive photonics-based biosensors that rapidly identify bacterial presence, ensuring immediate response and intervention. Besides research, she likes to practice photography and travel.

          THROugh their eyes: life after Retinoblastoma
          Nicola o'donnell

          Summary

          “Your child has cancer” are words that no one wants to think about, let alone hear. Annually, 50~ children in UK families will receive a diagnosis of Retinoblastoma, a rare childhood eye cancer. Although treatable, many children end up having an eye removed to save their life, or experience lifelong facial changes and/or visual impairment.

          Having had and being treated for any childhood cancer can lead to emotional challenges. For individuals who have had Retinoblastoma, these are unique and wide-ranging; some may pass on a faulty gene to their future children, others are at risk of developing second cancers, and most are likely to experience some distress.

          Once in remission from cancer, individuals and families can be left ‘in limbo’. My PhD investigates the survivorship journey towards life without Retinoblastoma or treatment, but with potential impact on wellbeing. Little is known about the psychological challenges experienced by these young people; the evidence generated from my PhD aims to develop a novel intervention for this group.

          About Nicola

          Nicola is a final-year PhD student in the Department of Health Sciences, funded by the Childhood Eye Cancer Trust. As a health psychologist and academic, she aspires to influence paediatric cancer care through both clinical practice and research. Her PhD work aims to develop a novel psychological intervention for teenagers and young adults who had the rare eye cancer, Retinoblastoma, when they were children. She enjoys working alongside individuals with lived experience to create meaningful impact.

          "Little is known about the psychological challenges experienced by these young people..."

          "Little is known about the psychological challenges experienced by these young people..."

            "By understanding these dynamics, we can better navigate the challenges and opportunities facing heritage institutions and festivals in a post-pandemic world."

            "By understanding these dynamics, we can better navigate the challenges and opportunities facing heritage institutions and festivals in a post-pandemic world."

              Creative Heritage Engagement: Commercialisation Vs Therapeutic Role
              Qian (Iffy) Wang

              Summary

              The Covid-19 pandemic has had a multifaceted impact on the daily operations and economic pressures on cultural institutions, resulting in income losses, systemic inequalities, and reshaping cultural practices.

              My research aims to explore how the Covid-19 pandemic has affected public participation and the creative economy across Chinese and UK heritage institutions. By comparing national heritage institutions and arts festivals in both countries, the study aims to understand how they engage in creative economic activities, provide therapeutic experiences, and handle tensions between using heritage for commercial purposes and their therapeutic roles. My research could help cultural institutions to investigate vulnerability and inequality in their heritage management processes, and provide insights into how the Covid-19 pandemic has reshaped heritage management practices in China and the UK.

              By understanding these dynamics, we can better navigate the challenges and opportunities facing heritage institutions and festivals in a post-pandemic world.

              About Qian

              Qian is a second-year PhD student at the Department of Archaeology. With a background in heritage management, her research concentrates on how the Covid-19 pandemic influenced public participation and the creative economy within Chinese and UK heritage management: a comparative study of heritage institutions and arts festivals. She enjoys communicating with people from different cultural backgrounds and is also a Salsa, Bachata, and Kizomba dancer.

              Secrets of photosynthesis
              SABINA Musial

              Summary

              Plants are some of the most important organisms on the planet. They create the oxygen that we breathe and the food that we eat. They also make their own food by capturing CO2 from the air. But when thinking about photosynthesis, we rarely think about algae.

              These extraordinary organisms living in the oceans are responsible for about half of global CO2. Their task is difficult – water contains less CO2 than air, so they have evolved mechanisms, which allow them to work around this problem to photosynthesise efficiently. By studying algae we can learn how to include these solutions into plants and create improved crops that could help feeding the world’s growing population.

              About Sabina

              Sabina did her undergraduate and masters degree in Sheffield after coming to the UK from her native Poland. During this time she developed an interest in understanding how do proteins work by studying their structures. In 2021, she started a PhD at the University of York Biology Department where she spends her days in the lab trying to understanding the proteins involved in algal photosynthesis.

              "By studying algae we can... create improved crops that could help feeding the world’s growing population."

              "By studying algae we can... create improved crops that could help feeding the world’s growing population."

                "...archaeology is a pivotal practice to improve the development in Indonesia..."

                "...archaeology is a pivotal practice to improve the development in Indonesia..."

                  Can Archaeology Build a Better Society in Indonesia?
                  Tondi Siregar

                  Summary

                  This project investigates the role of archaeology as a science and practice in Indonesia: a large archipelago country with a population of more than 250 million people spread over 38 provinces with many cultural and ethnic backgrounds. This study will ask how archaeology could create balance and perform in the midst of modernity.

                  In the development of a country like Indonesia, it is very difficult for both the government, and civil society, to establish a basic understanding regarding culture and heritage. A singular approach to archaeology and heritage is difficult as the region has its own identity and political interests regarding development, which become the economic backbone of the region. For instance, Jakarta has a modern economic infrastructure which is filled with skyscrapers, whilst Bali is strong with its cultural and natural tourism as the main economic foundation of the city. These things are strongly influenced by both the geographical conditions and historical background of each region.

                  As a big picture of how big Indonesia’s potential is in this matter, it consists of at least five layers of culture. I argue that archaeology is a pivotal practice to improve the development in Indonesia, not only from the economic aspect, but also as an agency to create new approaches that can be an option as a proponent of facing globalization. By tracing the social and cultural histories in Jakarta’s Old Town, this project aims to narrate the discourse, policy making and economic impact through cultural tourism. Relying on the public perceptions and documents with laws and regulations, archives, interviews and reports, this project will shed light on the understanding and importance of archaeology in shaping Jakarta’s Old Town into a cultural area, and the positive impact on how cultural heritage could have a big impact from social, economic and political perspectives.

                  About Tondi

                  Tondi is a final-year PhD student in the Department of Archaeology at the University of York from Jakarta, Indonesia. His research focuses on how archaeology could influence and play a pivotal role in Indonesia's development. Through his research, he aims to contribute to the public's perspective on the importance of Indonesian heritage to shape Indonesia's future.

                  “Catch Me If You Can”: Sweet solution for cancer treatment
                  Yumiko Uno

                  Summary

                  In my research, I'm looking into how changing the sugars on cancer cells could help activate the patient's immune system to fight cancer better.

                  These sugars, unlike the ones we eat, form a layer around cells, kind of like the shell of a peanut M&M. They act like IDs on cell surfaces, helping the immune system tell what's part of our body (self) and what's a threat (non-self), like viruses or germs. But here's the tricky part: cancer cells use a sneaky trick by showing a sugar that looks human-like, let's call it sugar A, to hide from the immune system. So, our plan is to step in and swap this sugar A with sugar B. This switch would make cancer cells easier for the immune system to recognize, leading to a stronger immune response against them.

                  About Yumiko

                  Yumiko, a Japanese PhD student in the Department of Chemistry, brings a unique perspective to her research. With a background in Veterinary medicine, she's passionately committed to leveraging the body's immune system to combat cancer. Her focus lies particularly on prostate cancer, a disease affecting around 52,000 men in the UK annually.

                  "This switch would make cancer cells easier for the immune system to recognize..."

                  "This switch would make cancer cells easier for the immune system to recognize..."

                    2024 WINNERS

                    1ST PLACE

                    Jack Stenning, Department of Biology

                    Catching Cancer Resistance with Calling Cards

                    2ND PLACE & PEOPLE'S CHOICE

                    Minahil Khan, School of Physics, Engineering & Technology

                    Keeping Liquids Free From Bacterial Contamination

                    3RD PLACE

                    Nicola O'Donnell, Department of Health Sciences

                    Through Their Eyes: Life after retinoblastoma

                    JUDGING PANEL AND PRESENTERS

                    Our 2024 judging panel and presenters

                    In addition to our People's Choice Award, the work of our 3MT finalists was also reviewed by our panel, for first, second and third place prizes. We were delighted to welcome members of our panel from a wide range of disciplines to help us choose our winner.

                    Read on below for a bit of background on each of our panelists and speakers across the day.

                    Judges

                    Professor Kate Arnold

                    Dean of the York Graduate Research School and Professor of Ecology in the Environment and Geography Department, University of York

                    Having been Dean of the York Graduate Research School since September 2020, Kate has strategic oversight of over 2,400 postgraduate researchers.

                    An ecologist by background, for over 20 years she has carried out research at the interface of science, policy and regulation. Her current projects, based in York's Department of Environment and Geography, are investigating the effects of environmental change, including chemical contaminants and habitat management, on wildlife.

                    From 2018-2020, she worked for Defra heading up an EU exit strategy team focusing on circular economy and single-use plastic policies.

                    Linda Ko Ferrigno

                    University Impact Manager, University of York

                    Linda has worked in a number of roles across the research ecosystem in both the US and the UK. She did a PhD in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology at Northwestern University and a postdoc at Columbia University in Cancer Biology. After deciding she had no interest whatsoever in becoming a bench scientist, she worked as a Senior Editor at Cell and Molecular Cell prior to moving to the UK in 2001. In Cambridge (UK) Linda served as the Information and Communication Specialist at the MRC Cancer Cell Unit and later as the Research Funding Manager at Yorkshire Cancer Research. Her experience in a knowledge transfer role at the University of Leeds then led her to her current position as the University Impact Manager at York where she oversaw the impact submission to REF2021.

                    Francisca D'Rozario

                    PhD Student, School of Physics, Engineering and Technology, University of York

                    Francisca is a third-year PhD student in the School of Physics, Engineering and Technology. Her research involves studying the behaviour of synthetic DNA bound to gold surfaces with potential applications in Electronics and Information Technology. Besides her research, Fran competes in street dance, represents York at the Yorkshire Korfball League, and loves to go bouldering with her friends. She believes that DNA nanotechnology will solve major environmental problems such as the universal energy crisis and global warming.

                    Abhishek Das

                    Head of Structured Finance, CaixaBank

                    Abhishek has been working in investment banking and finance for over 20 years for global institutions such as NatWest and MUFG Bank in the UK and in the Middle East. His specialisms are in project and infrastructure financing where he has more recently specialised in large-scale renewable energy financings and energy transition in the Europe, Middle East and Africa (EMEA) region. Since 2022, he has held the position of Head of Structured Finance UK for CaixaBank, the largest bank in Iberia (Spain and Portugal) and the leading Sustainable Finance lender in Europe, where he is responsible for originating transactions across project and infrastructure finance, sustainable finance as well as real estate finance. 

                    As an alumnus of The University of York and a member of Langwith College, he graduated in 2001 with a BSc (Hons) in Economics. Thereafter, in 2003, he graduated with an MSc in Finance & Economics from The London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE). He is also the Director of a company specialising in Italian Renaissance art. 

                    Harry Whittaker

                    Author and broadcaster

                    Harry Whittaker is an author and broadcaster. After a decade in radio, with stints at the BBC and in the commercial sector, his first fiction title for adults became an instant Sunday Times Number One Bestseller. Atlas: The Story of Pa Salt was nominated for Fiction Book of the Year at the British Book Awards. It won the Adlibris prize in Sweden and Finland, the Dutch Platinum Award, and the Booksellers New Zealand Award for bestselling international book.

                    Rosie and the Friendship Angel, from the Guardian Angels series, was named as one of the best books for children in 2022 by The Times.

                    Away from writing, Harry is a member of one of the UK’s most renowned improv troupes. You’ll currently find them making up new episodes of Doctor Who, or stories from the world of the Twilight Zone.

                    Harry read Writing, Directing and Performance at the University of York, and still lives in the city.

                    Event Compere

                    James Coe

                    Senior Partner and Head of Higher Education, Counterculture Partnership LLP

                    James is a proud alumnus of the University of York where he studied for a Masters in Public Administration. James is a Senior Partner and Head of Higher Education at specialist consultancy firm Counterculture, he is the Associate Editor for Research and Innovation at Wonkhe, and the author of The New University: Local Solutions to a Global Crisis. James is originally from Darlington, a new-ish and besotted dad to Olive, and a long-suffering Newcastle United fan.

                    Guest Speaker

                    Julian Richards

                    Archaeologist, writer, broadcaster and educator

                    Julian Richards is an archaeologist, writer, broadcaster an educator with a passion for bringing the past to life.  His long career has involved field archaeology, TV and radio, museum gallery design and lots of teaching to all ages, abilities and interests. His long term (and continuing) obsession with Stonehenge has led to fascinating collaborations  with artists, musicians and Druids.

                    Professor Kate Arnold, Dean of the York Graduate Research School (University of York)

                    Professor Kate Arnold, Dean of the York Graduate Research School (University of York)

                    Linda Ko Ferrigno, University Impact Manager (University of York)

                    Linda Ko Ferrigno, University Impact Manager (University of York)

                    Francisca D'Rozario, PhD Student, School of Physics, Engineering and Technology (University of York)

                    Francisca D'Rozario, PhD Student, School of Physics, Engineering and Technology (University of York)

                    Abhishek Das, Head of Structured Finance (CaixaBank)

                    Abhishek Das, Head of Structured Finance (CaixaBank)

                    Harry Whittaker, Author and Broadcaster

                    Harry Whittaker, Author and Broadcaster

                    James Coe, Senior Partner and Head of Higher Education (Counterculture)

                    James Coe, Senior Partner and Head of Higher Education (Counterculture)

                    Julian Richards, Archaeologist, Writer, Broadcaster and Educator

                    Julian Richards, Archaeologist, Writer, Broadcaster and Educator

                    Judging Criteria and Prizes

                    2024 Prizes

                    1st place - iPad
                    Jack Stenning, Catching Cancer Resistance with Calling Cards

                    2nd place - £150 voucher
                    Minahil Khan, Keeping Liquids Free From Bacterial Contamination

                    3rd place - £75 voucher
                    Nicola O'Donnell, Through Their Eyes: Life after retinoblastoma

                    People's choice - £75 voucher
                    Minahil Khan, Keeping Liquids Free From Bacterial Contamination

                    For first, second and third place, our panel worked to the following criteria:

                    Comprehension and content

                    • Did the presentation provide an understanding of the background and significance to the research question being addressed, while explaining terminology and avoiding jargon?
                    • Did the presentation clearly describe the impact and/or results of the research, including conclusions and outcomes?
                    • Did the presentation follow a clear and logical sequence?
                    • Was the thesis topic, research significance, results/impact and outcomes communicated in language appropriate to a non-specialist audience?
                    • Did the presenter spend adequate time on each element of their presentation - or did they elaborate for too long on one aspect or was the presentation rushed?

                    Engagement and communication

                    • Did the oration make the audience want to know more?
                    • Was the presenter careful not to trivialise or generalise their research?
                    • Did the presenter convey enthusiasm for their research?
                    • Did the presenter capture and maintain their audience's attention?
                    • Did the speaker have sufficient stage presence, eye contact and vocal range; maintain a steady pace, and have a confident stance?
                    • Did the PowerPoint slide enhance the presentation - was it clear, legible, and concise?